Old Time Pizza
  • Photos
  • Menu
  • Location
  • Work Hours
  • Business info
  • Reviews

Old Time Pizza Menu

Menu Old Time Pizza-1
Menu Old Time Pizza-1
Menu Old Time Pizza-2
Menu Old Time Pizza-2
Menu Old Time Pizza-3
Menu Old Time Pizza-3
Menu Old Time Pizza-4
Menu Old Time Pizza-4

Chicken

Piece Chicken
$18.79
Piece Chicken All Dark
$20.60

Salads

Applesauce Salad
$1.25
Cole Slaw Salad
$1.25

Sides

Nachos And Cheese
$4.01
Breadsticks
$3.50

Drinks

Fountain Drinks
$2.00
Canned Pop
$0.95

Sandwiches

Super Sandwich
$6.62
Pizza sauce, pepperoni, sausage, hamburger, ham, onions, mushrooms, green peppers, green olives, black olives, mozzarella cheese and baked in oven
Gyro Sandwich
$6.62
Pita bread, gayo meat, onions, lettuce, tomatoes and tzatziki cucumber sauce

At Old Time Pizza, the menu is a delightful mix of hearty meals and savory sides that promise to satisfy any craving. Let's take a closer look at some of their standout offerings.

For those in the mood for chicken, you can't go wrong with the Piece Chicken or the Piece Chicken All Dark. Each piece is fried to crispy perfection, delivering that irresistible crunch with every bite. It's a classic comfort food that hits all the right notes.

When it comes to fresh and light options, their Applesauce Salad and Cole Slaw Salad are the go-to choices. The Applesauce Salad is a refreshing twist, offering a sweet contrast with its crisp ingredients. Meanwhile, the Cole Slaw Salad is a classic, featuring creamy dressing that balances the crunch of the cabbage perfectly – a great side for any main dish.

For those who enjoy a good snack, Nachos and Cheese are a must-try. The crispy chips, generously covered with gooey cheese, make for an irresistible treat that pairs well with almost anything. If you're in the mood for something more filling, the Breadsticks are a great choice – warm, soft, and perfect for dipping into marinara or your favorite sauce.

As for beverages, Old Time Pizza keeps things simple yet satisfying with a range of Fountain Drinks and Canned Pop, ensuring there's a refreshing option for everyone.

Lastly, if you’re craving a satisfying sandwich, the Super Sandwich and Gyro Sandwich are the highlights. The Super Sandwich is packed with flavorful meats and fresh veggies, while the Gyro Sandwich offers that authentic Greek taste, complete with tender, seasoned meat wrapped in a warm pita.

With such a variety of options, Old Time Pizza’s menu promises something for everyone, from savory chicken to fresh salads and comforting sides.

Old Time Pizza

Old Time Pizza in New Paris, IN offers a classic dining experience with a range of options including pizza, broasted chicken, salads, and sides. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, this restaurant is perfect for families, groups, and individuals. Enjoy their happy hour specials, outdoor seating, and excellent service. Try their renowned broasted chicken, praised for its moist and flavorful taste. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Old Time Pizza is a must-try for delicious food in a cozy setting.

Follow Us
  • Yelp
  • tripadvisor
Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.